Can You Get Diabetes From Eating Too Much Sugar?

Eating too much sugar doesn’t directly cause diabetes. However, there is a correlation (association) between being overweight or having obesity and type 2 diabetes. Over time, consuming too many foods and beverages, including those high in sugar, may lead to weight gain.  Excessive weight gain can increase your risk of developing type 2 diabetes.

Correlation means there is an association between two variables. However, it doesn’t mean that a change in one variable will always lead to the other variable. Causation means there is a cause-and-effect relationship or that a change in one thing causes a change in another thing. 

This article discusses sugar and its association with diabetes, symptoms of too much or too little sugar, and sugar intake in people with diabetes.

Grace Cary / Getty Images

In Type 1 or 2 Diabetes, Sugar Isn’t a Direct Cause

Because diabetes is associated with high blood glucose (blood sugar) levels, it seems reasonable to assume that consuming too much sugar causes it. However, no quality literature cites sugar intake as a direct cause of type 1 or type 2 diabetes.

How Can People Get Diabetes?

Type 1 diabetes is not associated with diet and lifestyle habits. Rather, genetics and environmental risk factors are thought to play a role.

Having a parent or sibling with type 1 diabetes means you have a higher risk for type 1 diabetes. In the United States, white people are more often diagnosed with type 1 diabetes than African American and Hispanic or Latino people.

Type 2 diabetes is a complex, multifactorial disease with many different causes and risk factors. Some risk factors are lifestyle-related, such as being physically inactive or being overweight.

Other risk factors for type 2 diabetes include:

  • Having prediabetes (in which average blood sugar levels are high but not high enough to diagnose diabetes)
  • Being 45 years of age or older
  • Having an immediate family member (parent or sibling) with type 2 diabetes
  • Having had gestational diabetes (diabetes that begins during pregnancy)

People of African American, Hispanic or Latino, American Indian, Alaska Native, Pacific Islander, or Asian American heritage are more often diagnosed with type 2 diabetes than white people in the United States.

Read more  Alcohol and Type 2 Diabetes: What You Need to Know

Type 2 diabetes may be prevented or delayed by making positive lifestyle changes. These include following a healthy eating pattern, participating in regular physical activity, and losing weight if you’re overweight.

Verywell Health prefers to use inclusive terminology. But when citing health authorities or research, the terms for gender, sex, or racial groups from those sources are used.

What Are the Symptoms of Too Much Sugar?

In people without diabetes or prediabetes, the body is pretty good at regulating blood glucose levels and keeping them in a normal range. However, if blood glucose levels get too high (hyperglycemia) due to insulin resistance, not enough insulin, or other reasons, there are some symptoms to watch out for.

Common symptoms of high blood glucose levels include:

  • Excessive thirst
  • Increased urination
  • Increased hunger
  • Blurry vision
  • Fatigue
  • Frequent yeast infections

In more severe cases, hyperglycemia may also cause:

  • Unexplained weight loss
  • Sweet-smelling or “fruity” breath
  • Stomach pain, nausea, or vomiting
  • Cuts or sores that take a long time to heal
  • Numbness or tingling in your hands or feet

Symptoms of Too Little Sugar

On the opposite end of the spectrum, not eating sugar also does not have a direct effect on the development of diabetes.  However, too little glucose in the blood (hypoglycemia), or low blood sugar, can be dangerous. Here are some symptoms to look for:

  • Fast heartbeat
  • Shaking
  • Sweating, chills, or clamminess
  • Feeling nervous or anxious
  • Feeling irritable or confused
  • Feeling dizzy
  • Increased hunger

If you are at risk for developing low blood glucose levels, be sure to become familiar with the signs and symptoms, as well as how to treat it.

People With Diabetes Can Have Sugar


If you have diabetes, it doesn’t mean you can no longer eat sugar. Sugar, like any other food, can fit into a well-balanced diet when consumed in moderation. When eating sugary foods, you can minimize the blood glucose response and increase your feeling of satiety by adding sources of protein and fat.

Below are more tips for incorporating some of your favorite foods into your diet with diabetes while still successfully managing your blood glucose levels.

Mindful Intake

Being mindful of your food and beverage intake means focusing on your thoughts, emotions, and physical sensations while eating. Paying attention to your hunger and fullness cues is another important aspect of mindful eating.

For example, eat when you are hungry but not starving, and stop eating when you are no longer hungry and before you are overfull. Here are some tips for eating more mindfully:

Read more  Tired all the time? Here’s why

  • Eat slowly.
  • Take smaller bites.
  • Don’t skip meals.
  • Serve smaller portions.
  • Use smaller plates and bowls.
  • Utilize all your senses to notice the sight, sound, smell, taste, and texture of your food.
  • Think about where the food came from and who prepared it.
  • Avoid distractions, such as cell phones or TV.

Foods Swaps

Sometimes you may be craving something sweet, but there are several ways to still indulge without overdoing it. One such way is through food swaps or choosing a similar, healthier food option that will still satisfy your craving.

For example, instead of milk chocolate, choose dark chocolate. Another swap could be enjoying plain Greek yogurt sweetened with a slight drizzle of honey mixed with some berries and a dash of ground cinnamon rather than ice cream. Instead of topping your pancake with butter and syrup, try topping it with some nut butter and fresh fruit.

The options are endless, and you might find a new favorite way to indulge your sweet tooth while still adding some nutrients to your diet.

Sugar Alternatives 

If you walk down the baking aisle or the grocery store’s health supplement section, you will find many sugar alternatives. These include artificial sweeteners, sugar alcohols, and novel (natural) no- or low-calorie sweeteners.

Artificial sweeteners, also called nonnutritive sweeteners, can be 200 to 700 times sweeter than table sugar. They are synthetically created and do not contain any calories, sugar, vitamins, or minerals. The FDA has approved several as food additives.

Some artificial sweeteners include aspartame (NutraSweet or Equal), saccharin (Sweet and Low, Sweet Twin), and sucralose (Splenda).

Sugar alcohols are also created synthetically, usually from sugars themselves. They are not as sweet as artificial sweeteners, but still sweeter than table sugar. They are considered low-calorie sweeteners. They can cause stomach pain, bloating, gas, or diarrhea if consumed in large quantities.

Examples of sugar alcohol sugar substitutes include xylitol, erythritol, maltitol, and sorbitol.

Novel sweeteners are created from natural plant sources, though they are still processed to become what you see on store shelves. They are also considered low-calorie sweeteners and won't contribute to big spikes in blood sugar. Some examples include allulose, monk fruit extract, and stevia.

Read more  Study: Prediabetes Can Progress in Just One Year

Grocery Shopping and Nutrition Labels

Following a healthy diet is important whether you have diabetes or not. However, sometimes it can get a bit trickier trying to find out how to eat to best manage your diabetes. You might need to pay more attention to nutrition labels and ingredients when shopping at the grocery store.

If your healthcare provider has recommended you stay within a certain amount of carbohydrates per day, learning how to read a nutrition facts label is critical. Look at the grams of total carbohydrates, but also aim to include foods that are higher in fiber and have lower added sugars. 

Knowing where carbohydrates come from is just as important as how many carbohydrates you eat. If you have any questions about how many carbohydrates are right for you or learning how to read a nutrition label, a registered dietitian or diabetes educator can help you.

Fill your grocery cart with plenty of whole fruits, vegetables, whole grains, low-fat dairy, and lean protein sources. Include healthy fats such as olive oil, avocados, nuts, and seeds. Limit foods high in added sugars, saturated fats, and sodium.

Summary

Eating too much sugar is not a direct cause of diabetes. Consuming too many calories may lead to weight gain over time, which can increase your risk of developing type 2 diabetes.

Type 1 diabetes is an autoimmune condition thought to be associated with genetics and environmental triggers. There is a genetic component to type 2 diabetes, too. But, lifestyle-related risk factors can also increase the risk, such as being overweight or not exercising. 

People with diabetes may experience symptoms of high or low blood sugar levels. Symptoms of high blood sugar include blurry vision or increased hunger, urination, and/or thirst. Symptoms of low blood sugar include dizziness, shakiness, irritability, fast heartbeat, and confusion. 

People with diabetes may still include sugar and sweet foods in their diets and control their blood sugar levels by eating mindfully, using sugar alternatives, and paying attention to nutrition labels at the grocery store.

A Word From Verywell 

If you are concerned about your sugar intake and risk for diabetes, meet with your healthcare provider and a registered dietitian. They can help assess your risk for diabetes, as well as find ways to create healthier eating habits.

Focus on your overall dietary pattern, aiming to include a variety of nutritious foods. Also, incorporate physical activity and movement into your daily routine.

References

Recommended For You

About the Author: Tung Chi